Home / Engagement Rings

Non Traditional Engagement Rings

No Filters Applied
60 Results
JM® Care Plans
New hassle-free protection plans so you can keep your jewelry looking as good as the day you got it.
Learn More
The Esperanza Oval Double Prong Solitaire
$1,950
The Bennett Marquise Solitaire
$1,875
The Horizon Ring
$3,200
The Laguna Ring
$5,405
Mined in the USA
The Reese 1.81 ct Long Cushion Teal Montana Sapphire Ring
$7,296
The Jaden Three Baguette Band
$2,370
The Amanda Emerald Cut Solitaire
$2,485
The Toi et Moi 3.04 ct Oval Galaxy Diamond and .50 ct Round Diamond Ring
$11,188
The Toi et Moi 3.59 ct Oval Galaxy and .50 ct Round Diamond Ring
$11,675
The Chelsea .86 ct Emerald Cut and .81 ct Elongated Pear Sapphire Ring
$3,812
The Marina 1.17 ct Cushion Australian Sapphire Ring
$3,789
The Griffin .78 ct Oval Australian Sapphire Ring
$3,750
The Chelsea 2.01 ct Cushion and 1.02 ct Oval Australian Sapphire Ring
$9,987
The Elwood 1.93 cttw Round Australian Sapphire Ring
$2,764
The Blaine 1.64 ct Emerald Cut Australian Sapphire Ring
$5,339
The Blaine 2.65 cttw Oval Australian Sapphire Band
$2,919
Mined in the USA
The Madison .88 ct Oval and .48 ct Octagon Montana Sapphire Ring
$4,170
Mined in the USA
The Blaine 1.84 cttw Round, Oval, and Emerald Cut Montana Sapphire Ring
$5,509
Mined in the USA
The Reese 1.33 ct Cushion Montana Sapphire Ring
$5,002
Mined in the USA
The Madison 1.15 ct Round and 1.13 ct Oval Montana Sapphire Ring
$4,197
Mined in the USA
The Reese .99 ct Oval and .86 ct Pear Blue Montana Sapphire Ring
$2,922
The Tamayo Marquise Ring
$4,920
The Agnes 1.18 cttw Round Sapphire Ring
$1,380
The Blaine 2.02 cttw Cushion, Oval, and Round Australian Sapphire Ring
$2,608
The Lena 2.55 ct Pear Clear Rustic Diamond Ring
$7,366
The Lyell 2.44 ct Round Grey Rustic Diamond Ring
$4,802
The Lyell 3.31 ct Pear Clear and Peach Rustic Diamond Ring
$9,398
The Marseille .51 ct Pear Champagne Diamond Ring
$4,757
The Jaden Band
$1,860
The Esperanza Emerald Cut Double Prong Solitaire
$2,025
The Malia Ring
$4,665
The Bennett Oval Solitaire
$1,850
Sale
The Dillon 1.87 ct Round Blue Sapphire Ring
$6,356 $8,474
The Aquila 2.48 ct Cushion Galaxy Diamond Ring
$6,426
The Powell 1.72 ct Oval Rustic Diamond Ring
$3,850
Sale
The Calisto 1.82 ct Round Galaxy Diamond Halo Ring
$3,585 $4,780
Sale
The Everest 2.25 ct Round Rustic Diamond Ring
$6,340 $7,459
The Stella 1.14 ct Round Galaxy Diamond Halo Ring
$5,955
Sale
The Denali 1.35 ct Pear Rustic Diamond Ring
$3,125 $4,166
Sale
The Atlantis 2.86 ct Oval Blue Sapphire with .22 ct Side Stone Ring
$10,141 $11,930
The Maya 1.11 ct Asscher Rustic Diamond Solitaire
$5,226
The Bennett 1.69 ct Oval Rustic Diamond Bezel Solitaire
$4,794
The Sezanne 2.21 ct Long Hexagon Rustic Diamond Ring
$7,056
The Bennett 1.21 ct Hexagon Rustic Bezel Solitaire
$2,789
The Maya 2.04 ct Long Cushion Rustic Diamond Solitaire
$5,203
The Lennox 2.97 ct Oval Galaxy Diamond Signet Style Ring
$9,675
The Lennox 2.03 ct Long Hexagon Rustic Diamond Signet Ring
$7,642
The Lennox 2.18 ct Oval Galaxy Diamond Signet Style Ring
$5,663
The Sezanne 1.05 ct Hexagon Rustic Diamond Ring
$4,470
The Maeve 7.46 ct Oval Teal Sapphire Solitaire
$14,988
Mined in the USA
The Maren 1.94 ct Marquise Montana Sapphire Solitaire
$5,390
The Amanda 2.45 ct Emerald Cut Teal Sapphire Double Band Solitaire
$11,960
The Maya 1.76 ct Emerald Cut Pale Blue Sapphire Solitaire
$5,120
Mined in the USA
The Charlotte 2.29 ct Round Montana Sapphire Solitaire
$14,330
Mined in the USA
The Maeve 3.86 ct Round Montana Sapphire Solitaire
$18,890
The Betty 2.14 ct Cushion Garnet Ring
$4,784
The Sierra 2.42 ct Round Rustic Diamond Ring
$7,225
The Acadia .45 ct Pear Rustic Diamond Ring
$2,513
Sale
The Athena 1.10 ct Round Emerald Ring 14kyg
$8,988 $9,987
The Maya 2.06 ct Asscher Teal Sapphire Solitaire
$5,200

Custom & Heirloom

Find your One-of-a-Kind

Let your imagination run wild with custom pieces designed from scratch or new pieces crafted from heirloom stones.

start a custom design