For holiday delivery for all made-to-order rings, orders must be placed by 3pm MST on the following days:

- Christmas Eve: Order by November 10, 2025

- New Year’s Eve: Order by November 17, 2025

There is no visual difference to the naked eye between a natural diamond and lab-grown diamond. They all have varying types of color, clarity, size, and shape and score a 10/10 on the Mohs hardness scale. The only way to tell the difference between a natural diamond and lab-grown diamond is with specialized equipment.

While natural diamonds and lab-grown diamonds have the same chemical, physical, and optical properties, the rarity of a natural diamond is what truly sets the two apart from each other. Natural diamonds are finite and rare whereas there is no limit to how many lab-grown diamonds can be made in the future. This can ultimately impact the value of a lab-grown diamond overtime.

Whether you’re shopping in-store or online, our financing options can help make your dream jewelry a reality. Click here to learn more.

At Sarah O. Jewelry, we proudly offer a limited lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects on all of our pieces.

• First 6 Months: Our warranty covers any issues due to defects in workmanship or design.

• After 6 Months: Coverage is at the discretion of Sarah O. Jewelry. We reserve the right to determine whether an issue qualifies as a manufacturing defect or as standard wear and tear.

What’s Included

• One free resize after purchase (Eternity styles and alternative metal designs are excluded outside the 30 day exchange window)

• Replacement of one melee under 0.10 cts or 3mm in length

• Complimentary cleanings, polishing, tightening, and inspections for the life of your piece

Please note: servicing your jewelry with a third-party jeweler will void this warranty.

About Wear and Tear

It’s normal for jewelry to require maintenance over time. Most repairs stem from everyday wear rather than defects. To minimize repairs, we recommend following our Care & Cleaning guidelines and removing your jewelry during hands-on activities. Any repairs or maintenance required will be priced out at a discounted rate.

Examples of standard wear and tear include:

• Bent or worn prongs leading to loose stones

• Discoloration of stones from climate or chemical exposure

• Metal discoloration from skin pH or chemical exposure

• Chipped stones (diamonds, precious, or semi-precious)

• Scratches on metal from everyday use Bent, misshapen, or broken shanks from lifestyle or activities

• Metal tarnishing or rhodium wear

• Resizing beyond the initial complimentary resize, or cases where a new ring must be made

We've teamed up with Jewelers Mutual Group to offer hassle-free protection plans so you can keep your jewelry looking as good as the day you got it. View the JM® Care Plans we offer and choose what's best for you. Click here to learn more.