Sarah's Gift Guide

Valentine's Day Engagement Rings & Fine Jewelry

Shop our collection of cupid approved Valentine's Day gifts featuring timeless styles they'll cherish forever. Find the perfect piece for the person that means the most.

Shop By Type

Shop All Fine Jewelry

Love Is In The Air

Proposal Ready Rings

Looking to start "forever" this Valentine's Day? Sarah O.'s ready-to-ship rings are ready for your Valentine's Day proposal. Please place your order by 2/9 for Valentine's Day delivery.

Something for Everyone

Gifts Under $500

Gifts that shine

Sarah's Favorite Diamond Pieces

Valentine's Day Edit

Wear Your Heart

Pink Gemstones We Love

Galentine's Day

Permanent Jewelry

Permanent jewelry is a clasp-free chain that is welded directly onto you, creating a piece that you don’t have to take off or fuss over. Lasting pieces like this are perfect for representing a special friendship, memory, or just because! We offer a selection of 14k gold chain options and measure your wrist to find your custom fit. Appointments are available at our Tennyson showroom.